Frame Shift

Galilean frames · work · kinetic energy

Galilean frames · work · kinetic energy

Same push. Same cart.
Two verdicts.

A 2.0 kg cart sits at rest on a frictionless track, and a constant 4.0 N force pulls it to the right for 3.0 s. Observer A, standing beside the track, says the force gave the cart kinetic energy. Observer B, riding past at 4.0 m/s, says the same force took kinetic energy away. Neither has made a mistake: velocity, displacement, kinetic energy and work all depend on who is watching. Yet W = ΔK holds for every inertial observer, and every observer agrees on what the winch’s battery spends.

Live: the same 3.0 s filmed by two cameras. Top: fixed to the track, beside A. Bottom: riding with B at 4.0 m/s.

Agree or not?Mass, force, elapsed time, acceleration and Δp are the same for every inertial observer. Velocity, displacement, kinetic energy and work belong to a frame.
Work follows the rulerW = FΔx, and each observer reads Δx off their own ruler, which may be moving. A force that points right the whole time can do negative work.
W = ΔK, every inertial frameNo inertial observer catches the theorem failing: work and kinetic energy both shift by −uΔp. An accelerating observer needs a fictitious force to keep it.
Who pays?The battery spends F × the string wound in, the same for everyone. A moving observer must count the track and the Earth too: their kinetic energy changes by uFΔt.
Stay in touch