Force on a Moving Charge · Guide · glidepathscience.org
GuideForce on a Moving Charge
Contents
This Guide explains the ideas and equations behind every Walkthrough step, Concept Challenge question and Predict round, in the order a textbook would take them. Part 1 prepares the Intro track and Part 2 the Advanced track; each takes about fifteen minutes to read. Every section ends with a worked example that is not one of the sim's own problems.
Part 1 · The essentials
A magnet that falls slowly through copper
Hold a strong magnet against a copper pipe and it falls off: copper is not magnetic in the everyday sense. Yet the same magnet dropped down the inside of the pipe drifts down slowly and steadily, while one dropped down a plastic pipe falls straight through. Nothing touches either magnet, and neither pipe attracts it. Something in the copper pushes back, and only while the magnet moves.
The difference is not magnetism but free charge. A metal is full of electrons that can drift through the whole piece; plastic has essentially none. The falling magnet turns out to be the force this sim is about, the force of a magnetic field on moving charges, at work on the copper's free electrons. The last section of Part 1 comes back to it.
To explain the slow fall we first need the force itself: which charges feel it, and which way it points.
The magnetic force: only moving charges, only across B
An electric field pushes on a charge whether it moves or not. A magnetic field exerts no force on a charge at rest, and on a moving charge it pushes sideways, at right angles to both the velocity and the field. The force on a charge q moving with velocity $\vec v$ through a magnetic field $\vec B$ is the cross product
$\vec F = q\vec v\times\vec B$ $|F| = {|q|}vB\sin\theta$
where θ is the angle between $\vec v$ and $\vec B$. Only the part of the velocity across the field counts: a charge moving along a field line feels nothing. B is measured in tesla (T); Earth's field is about 50 µT, a laboratory electromagnet about 1 T.
The direction comes from the right-hand rule. Point the fingers of your right hand along $\vec v$ and curl them toward $\vec B$: your thumb points along $\vec v\times\vec B$, the direction of the force on a positive charge. On a negative charge, such as an electron, the force points the opposite way, because q is negative. Forgetting that sign, or using the left hand, is the most common error with this law.
A force always at right angles to the velocity has a remarkable consequence for the path.
Circles at constant speed
Because $\vec F$ is always perpendicular to $\vec v$, the magnetic force does no work ($\vec F\cdot\vec v = 0$): it cannot change the particle's speed, only its direction. A force of constant size that stays at right angles to the velocity is a centripetal force, so a particle moving straight across a uniform field goes round a circle at constant speed. Setting the magnetic force equal to the centripetal force gives the radius:
${|q|}vB = \frac{mv^2}{r}$ $r = mv/{|q|}B$
Here m is the mass and v the speed. A heavier or faster particle makes a bigger circle; a stronger field or a larger charge, a smaller one. Since mv is the momentum p, this is also $r = p/{|q|}B$, a form that still holds near the speed of light. Expecting the force to speed the particle up, or reporting meters where centimeters are asked, are the usual errors.
The radius depends on the speed. The time to go around does not.
A period that ignores the speed
The time for one turn is the circumference divided by the speed. Using the radius we just found,
$T = \frac{2\pi r}{v} = 2\pi m/{|q|}B$ $f = 1/T = \frac{{|q|}B}{2\pi m}$
The speed cancels: a particle twice as fast runs around a circle twice as big, so particles with the same charge-to-mass ratio in the same field all take the same time per turn, at least well below the speed of light (Part 2 shows what changes near c). f is the cyclotron frequency, and $\omega = {|q|}B/m$ is the rate at which the velocity turns. The natural guess, that a faster particle laps more often, is wrong: two protons launched together at different speeds stay lined up on the same radius.
This is what makes the cyclotron possible: a voltage alternating at the fixed frequency f can push a circling particle every half turn, and as it speeds up and its orbit grows, it still arrives on time.
A velocity tilted toward the field adds a twist.
Helices: the part along B coasts
Split the velocity into a part along the field and a part across it. The part along B feels no force, so it carries the particle steadily along the field lines, while the part across B circles as before. Together they make a helix around the field lines. With θ the angle between $\vec v$ and $\vec B$,
$v_\parallel = v\cos\theta$ $v_\perp = v\sin\theta$ $r = mv\sin\theta/{|q|}B$ $\text{pitch} = (v\cos\theta)\,T$
The radius uses only the part across B, the period is still $2\pi m/{|q|}B$, and in one period the particle advances $v_\parallel T$ along B, the pitch. At θ = 90° the helix flattens into a circle; at θ = 0 the particle slides straight along the field. Because θ is measured from B, the cosine goes with the part along B; swapping sine and cosine is the usual slip. Electrons energized in Earth's magnetotail spiral along field lines like this into the polar atmosphere, where they make the auroras.
With only a magnetic field the speed never changes. An electric field changes that.
The velocity selector
Two parallel plates make a uniform electric field $\vec E$ that pushes a charge toward one plate with a force $q\vec E$, whatever its speed. Add a magnetic field at right angles to both $\vec E$ and the velocity, arranged so that $q\vec v\times\vec B$ pushes toward the other plate. The magnetic force grows with speed, the electric one does not, and at one speed they cancel:
$qE = qvB$ $v = E/B$
A particle at that speed flies straight through to a slit on the axis; slower ones bend one way, faster ones the other. The charge cancels and the mass never enters: a velocity selector sorts by speed alone, so protons, alpha particles and electrons at that speed all pass. The two forces must oppose: reverse one field and no speed passes; reverse both and they oppose again. Writing $v = B/E$ is a slip the units catch: (V/m)/T = m/s.
A particle that is not quite at that speed does something more interesting than miss.
When the balance is off: the electric field does work
Send a proton into a selector a little too slowly. The electric force wins at first, yet the proton does not crash: it swings back, again and again. The magnetic force never does work, but the electric force does: as the proton moves along $\vec E$ it speeds up, $qvB$ grows until it overtakes $qE$, and on the way back the field takes the energy away. Kinetic energy plus qV stays constant.
Seen from a frame moving along the plates at $E/B$, the electric field vanishes and the proton simply circles at its mismatch speed $|v_0 - E/B|$. Back in the lab that circle is carried along at $E/B$, so the speed ranges from $v_0$ up to $2E/B - v_0$. The smooth weave is a curtate trochoid, not a cycloid: cusps, where the particle stops for an instant, need a start from rest or at $2E/B$. Blaming the magnetic field for the speed changes is the tempting wrong explanation.
Once a beam has a known speed, or a known energy, the magnetic field can weigh its particles.
Weighing ions: the mass spectrometer
A mass spectrometer turns a difference in mass into a difference in position. Ions of charge q are accelerated from rest through a voltage V, then swing through half a circle in a uniform field and land a diameter, 2r, from the entrance:
$qV = \tfrac{1}{2}mv^2$ $v = \sqrt{2qV/m}$ $r = \frac{mv}{qB} = \sqrt{2mV/q}/B$ $x = 2r$
With the same energy, heavier ions move more slowly but carry more momentum, so r grows as $\sqrt m$ and the landing points spread out by mass. Dropping the ½ in the kinetic energy, or reporting r where the landing point 2r is asked, are the usual slips; masses must be real masses in kilograms (1 u = 1.661×10⁻²⁷ kg).
We now have everything needed to return to the copper pipe.
Back to the pipe: the force in the magnet's frame
From the falling magnet's point of view, the pipe streams upward past it, carrying its free electrons through the magnet's field. That field fans out from one pole and back in toward the other, so near the magnet it has a part across the pipe's axis, outward near one pole and inward near the other. An electron moving along the pipe through it feels $q\vec v\times\vec B$ directed around the pipe, one way above the magnet and the other way below: the free electrons circulate in two rings of current, in opposite senses.
A ring of current is itself a magnet. The ring below repels the falling magnet and the ring above pulls it back; the faster it falls, the stronger the currents, until the drag equals its weight and it falls at a steady terminal speed. Plastic has no free charges to push. A magnet at rest in copper feels nothing, which is why "copper is magnetic" cannot be the explanation.
That last remark hides a puzzle, since the magnetic force never does work. Part 2 resolves it, after working out the motion more carefully.
Part 2 · Going further
Solving the equations of motion
Newton's second law with the magnetic force alone is $m\,\mathrm{d}\vec v/\mathrm{d}t = q\vec v\times\vec B$. Take a uniform field along z, $\vec B = B\hat k$, and write the cross product out in components:
$\frac{\mathrm{d}v_x}{\mathrm{d}t} = \omega v_y$ $\frac{\mathrm{d}v_y}{\mathrm{d}t} = -\omega v_x$ $\frac{\mathrm{d}v_z}{\mathrm{d}t} = 0$ $\omega = qB/m$
Motion along the field is untouched. Differentiating once more gives $\mathrm{d}^2v_x/\mathrm{d}t^2 = -\omega^2v_x$, simple harmonic motion: $v_x = v_\perp\cos\omega t$, $v_y = -v_\perp\sin\omega t$, the two a quarter period apart. The minus sign fixes the sense: a positive charge turns clockwise as seen from the tip of $\vec B$, with angular velocity $-(qB/m)\hat k$, and a negative charge counterclockwise, whatever its launch or speed.
A circling charge is a current loop with moment $\mu = \tfrac{1}{2}{|q|}v_\perp r = \tfrac{1}{2}mv_\perp^2/B$, and for either sign it points against $\vec B$: circling charges weaken the field they sit in, the origin of plasma diamagnetism.
An electric field across B adds a steady motion on top of the circling.
E × B drift
With both fields, the Lorentz force is $q(\vec E + \vec v\times\vec B)$. In a frame moving at a slow velocity $\vec v_d$ the electric field is $\vec E\,' = \vec E + \vec v_d\times\vec B$, and one choice makes it vanish:
$\vec v_d = \frac{\vec E\times\vec B}{B^2}$ $|v_d| = E/B$ $\vec E\,' = \vec E + \vec v_d\times\vec B = 0$
In that frame every particle simply circles; in the lab each circle is carried along at $\vec v_d$, perpendicular to both fields. The drift contains neither q nor m: protons and electrons drift together, though their circles differ enormously, so in a plasma E × B drift moves the plasma without making a current. Expecting opposite charges to drift opposite ways is the usual slip.
The shape of the path depends on how the particle starts, and the drifting frame makes every case easy.
Cycloids, weaves and loops
A particle released from rest has velocity $-\vec v_d$ in the drifting frame, so it circles there at $E/B$ with radius $r = mv_d/{|q|}B$. In the lab that circle rolls along, tracing a cycloid: a cusp where the particle stops for an instant, and $2E/B$ at the top of each arch. Its reach across the drift is the circle's diameter:
$r = \frac{mv_d}{{|q|}B} = \frac{mE}{{|q|}B^2}$ $\text{reach} = 2mE/{|q|}B^2$
Starting at $v_0$ along the drift, the particle circles at $|v_0 - E/B|$: zero gives a straight line (the selector), less than $E/B$ a smooth weave, exactly $E/B$ (at $v_0 = 0$ or $2E/B$) a cycloid, and more, loops. Reporting the rolling circle's radius as the reach is the usual error.
The same picture explains how sharply a real velocity selector selects.
How finely a selector selects
In a selector set to pass $E/B$, a particle off by $\Delta v$ circles in the drifting frame at $|\Delta v|$, so between the plates it weaves within a band on one side of the axis:
$\text{band} = \frac{2m{|\Delta v|}}{{|q|}B}$ exit angle up to $\frac{{|\Delta v|}}{v}$
A slit admitting particles within a of the axis seems to pass any band narrower than a. But a weaving particle leaves the plates at an angle of up to $|\Delta v|/v$ and coasts to the slit; over a coast L it can stray $L|\Delta v|/v$. A stronger B shrinks the band but not that angle, so it does not always narrow the selector; a narrower slit, or a longer coast, does. Only the mismatch $\Delta v$ circles, never the whole speed.
Selecting speeds well is one half of a precise instrument; separating close masses is the other.
Mass resolution
In the mass spectrometer an ion lands at $x = 2\sqrt{2mV/q}/B$. Because x grows as the square root of m, a small fractional difference in mass gives half as large a fractional difference in landing point:
$x = 2\sqrt{2mV/q}/B$ $\Delta x/x \approx \tfrac{1}{2}\Delta m/m$
Forgetting the ½ doubles the predicted separation. Telling apart two masses that differ by $\Delta m$ needs a resolving power of at least $m/\Delta m$. N₂⁺ (28 u) and O₂⁺ (32 u) are easy. Molecules with the same mass number differ only through nuclear binding energies: CO₂⁺ and N₂O⁺, both 44 u, need about 3,900, beyond a simple magnetic sector.
All of this assumed that the particles move much more slowly than light. Electrons often do not.
Near the speed of light
The magnetic force law $\vec F = q\vec v\times\vec B$ holds at any speed, but Newton's second law must be written for the momentum, $\vec p = \gamma m\vec v$, where
$\gamma = 1/\sqrt{1 - v^2/c^2}$ $r = p/{|q|}B$ $\omega = {|q|}B/\gamma m$ $T = \frac{2\pi\gamma m}{{|q|}B}$
The force still does no work, so γ is constant and the orbit is still a circle, but its radius is set by the momentum and its period grows with γ. Near c, γ grows without limit while v barely changes: at 0.99c, γ = 7.09 and a turn takes about seven times as long as at low speed. Using mv near c underestimates the radius by γ.
That growing period is exactly what a cyclotron cannot tolerate.
The cyclotron and its limit
A cyclotron has two hollow D-shaped electrodes, the dees, in a uniform field, with an alternating voltage across the gap between them, tuned to the low-speed frequency $|q|B/2\pi m$. A particle crossing the gap twice per turn gains up to 2qV per turn. At the edge of the dees, radius R, its momentum is $p = qBR$, which fixes the final energy.
As the particle gains energy, γ creeps above 1 and each turn takes a little longer than the voltage's fixed period. The lags add up, roughly the sum of γ − 1 over the turns, in cycles; once the particle meets the gap a quarter cycle late, the voltage starts taking energy away. Electrons fall out of step within tens of keV, protons in the MeV range. A synchrocyclotron lowers the frequency as the particles speed up; an isochronous cyclotron makes B grow with radius. Only the gap's electric field changes the energy, never the magnetic force.
Accelerating charges have one more way to lose energy, which this sim leaves out.
The edge of the model: radiation
An accelerating charge radiates, and a circling charge always accelerates, at $a = \omega v$. At speeds well below c, Larmor's formula gives a power proportional to the circling kinetic energy, which therefore decays exponentially, by a factor e in a time τ:
$P = \frac{q^2a^2}{6\pi\varepsilon_0c^3}$ $\tau = 3\pi\varepsilon_0m^3c^3/(q^4B^2)$
The magnetic force still does no work; the radiation carries the energy away, so it is wrong to conclude that the energy cannot change. τ grows as the cube of the mass, so a proton's is 1,836³ ≈ 6.2×10⁹ times an electron's in the same field. Electrons in strong fields radiate strongly, the light of a synchrotron source; protons hardly radiate at all.
This sim leaves radiation out. Back to something it includes: the copper pipe, in numbers.
The pipe in numbers
For a small magnet of dipole moment m falling along the axis of a long, thin-walled pipe of radius a, wall w and conductivity σ, the induced currents give a drag F = kv with (Levin, da Silveira and Rizzato, 2006)
$k = \tfrac{45}{1024}\mu_0^2m^2\sigma w/a^4$ $v_t = Mg/k$ time constant $M/k$
M is the magnet's mass and m its moment, two letters easy to mix up. $M\,\mathrm{d}v/\mathrm{d}t = Mg - kv$ gives $v = v_t(1 - e^{-tk/M})$: the magnet reaches $v_t$ within about a tenth of a second. Because k falls as $1/a^4$, a pipe twice as wide lets the magnet fall sixteen times faster, and using the diameter for a gives that error. Real magnets are not points, so measured times differ by tens of percent.
The numbers say how much heat the pipe receives. The last puzzle is who delivers it.
Who does the work?
The magnetic force is perpendicular to the velocity in every frame, so it never does work. Yet the pipe heats at a rate equal to Mg times the terminal speed. In the lab, where the pipe is at rest, the magnet's field at each point of the pipe changes as it passes, and a changing magnetic field comes with a curling electric field (Faraday's law):
$\nabla\times\vec E = -\frac{\partial\vec B}{\partial t}$
That electric field drives the currents and does the work. In the magnet's frame the field is static and the moving electrons are deflected by $q\vec v\times\vec B$, the work coming from whatever keeps the pipe moving: what one observer calls magnetic, another calls electric. Either way the energy comes from the magnet's fall, not from gravity on the electrons or from friction.
Currents in a field are pushed sideways too, and that sideways push can be measured directly.
The Hall effect
A strip of width w and thickness t carries a current I across a field B along its thickness. Its carriers, n per cubic meter with charge q, drift along it, and $q\vec v\times\vec B$ pushes them toward one edge until the charge piled up there makes a field $E_H$ that balances the magnetic force: a velocity selector the carriers build for themselves. Then
$v_d = I/(nqwt)$ $E_H = v_d B$ $V_H = E_H w = IB/(nqt)$
The width cancels, so only the thickness t along B matters; using the width is the usual error. The sign of $V_H$ gives the sign of the carriers, and $R_H = 1/nq$ their density. A semiconductor has millions of times fewer carriers than copper, so milliamps give millivolts: that is how Hall sensors measure B. One free electron per copper atom is an estimate; copper's measured Hall coefficient is a quarter to a third smaller.
Reference
Common mistakes
- Using cos θ for the force. θ is measured from B, and only the part of v across B counts: $|F| = {|q|}vB\sin\theta$.
- Forgetting the sign of the charge. An electron is pushed opposite to $\vec v\times\vec B$.
- Expecting the magnetic force to change the speed. It is always perpendicular to v, so it does no work.
- Expecting a faster particle to lap sooner. At low speeds $T = 2\pi m/{|q|}B$ has no v in it.
- Confusing r and 2r. Ions land a diameter from the entrance, and a cycloid's reach is a diameter.
- Dropping the ½ in $qV = \tfrac{1}{2}mv^2$, or forgetting the ½ in $\Delta x/x \approx \tfrac{1}{2}\Delta m/m$.
- Thinking the selector cares about mass or charge. It passes $v = E/B$ for every particle.
- Using v instead of Δv for the band, or expecting a stronger B always to narrow a selector.
- Leaving γ out near c. $r = p/{|q|}B$ with $p = \gamma mv$, and the period grows with γ.
Equation sheet
| Part 1 | |
|---|---|
| force | $F = qv\times B$, $|F| = {|q|}vB\sin\theta$ |
| circle | $r = mv/{|q|}B$ |
| period | $T = 2\pi m/{|q|}B$, $f = 1/T$ (no v) |
| helix | $r = mv\sin\theta/{|q|}B$, $\text{pitch} = (v\cos\theta)\,T$ |
| selector | $v = E/B$ |
| spectrometer | $qV = \tfrac{1}{2}mv^2$, $r = \sqrt{2mV/q}/B$, lands at $x = 2r$ |
| Part 2 | |
|---|---|
| near c | $\omega = {|q|}B/\gamma m$, $r = p/{|q|}B$, $\gamma = 1/\sqrt{1 - v^2/c^2}$ |
| drift | $v_d = E/B$, along $\vec E\times\vec B$ |
| cycloid | from rest: $\text{reach} = 2mE/{|q|}B^2$ |
| selector band | $2m{|v - E/B|}/({|q|}B)$ |
| resolution | $x = 2\sqrt{2mV/q}/B$, $\Delta x/x \approx \tfrac{1}{2}\Delta m/m$ |
| radiation | $\tau = 3\pi\varepsilon_0m^3c^3/(q^4B^2)$ |
| pipe | $k = \tfrac{45}{1024}\mu_0^2m^2\sigma w/a^4$, $v_t = Mg/k$ |
| Hall | $V_H = IB/(nqt)$ |
Symbols: q charge · m mass, or in the pipe the magnet's dipole moment (A·m²) · M the magnet's mass · v speed, $v_0$ at the start · $v_d$ a drift speed (E × B, or the Hall carriers') · θ angle between v and B · E, B the fields · r radius · T period · f frequency · ω angular frequency · μ the orbit's magnetic moment · V accelerating voltage · x landing distance · p momentum · γ Lorentz factor · τ radiation time · k drag constant · σ conductivity · a the pipe's radius · w the pipe's wall, or the strip's width · t the strip's thickness · I current · n carrier density. 1 u = 1.661×10⁻²⁷ kg; e = 1.602×10⁻¹⁹ C.
Further reading
OpenStax, University Physics Volume 2, chapter 11, “Magnetic Forces and Fields,” an open textbook licensed CC BY-NC-SA 4.0 (openstax.org); D. J. Griffiths, Introduction to Electrodynamics, chapter 5; Y. Levin, F. L. da Silveira and F. B. Rizzato, “Electromagnetic braking: a simple quantitative model,” Am. J. Phys. 74, 815 (2006). The Field Manual lists the sim's constants and the model's limits.
Force on a Moving Charge v1.7 · © 2026 Dr. David Meier · CC BY-NC-SA 4.0 · glidepathscience.org